Should We Renovate or Buy a New Home?

This is an important financial decision, especially if you have a low interest rate on your current mortgage. The good news is that a $100,000 renovation versus purchasing a $600,000 home gives you two very different paths to consider.

Here are three reasons to choose each.

Option 1: Renovate your current home – $100,000

1. Preserve your existing mortgage rate.

If you currently have a 3% mortgage, this is a major financial advantage. Replacing that mortgage with a new loan at today’s higher rates could substantially increase your monthly payment. Renovating allows you to keep that favorable financing on your existing mortgage balance.

2. Spend significantly less money.

A $100,000 renovation is considerably less than purchasing a $600,000 home. You may avoid:

  • Real estate commissions when selling.
  • Closing costs on your new purchase.
  • Moving expenses.
  • Higher property taxes and insurance associated with a more expensive home.

3. Build value while staying where you are.

If the renovations improve your home’s functionality and appeal, you may increase its market value while creating the space you need. You also avoid the uncertainty and stress of buying and selling simultaneously.

Option 2: Move to a $600,000 home

1. Get the space you really need.

Sometimes a renovation simply cannot solve the problem. If you need additional bedrooms, a larger lot, a different floor plan, or a better location, moving may be the smarter long-term decision.

2. Avoid over-improving your current home.

Putting $100,000 into a home doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll get $100,000 back. If your neighborhood has a ceiling on home values, you could spend money that the market won’t recognize. Moving lets you purchase a home that already has the features you want.

3. Make a long-term lifestyle investment.

A new home may better accommodate your family, work, hobbies, and future plans. If you expect to stay for 10 years or longer, buying the right home now could be worth the additional expense.

Side-by-side financial comparison

ConsiderationRenovateMove
Project/purchase price$100,000$600,000
Existing 3% mortgageKeep itLikely replace it
Closing costsMinimalSignificant
Moving expensesNoneYes
Additional spaceDepends on projectPotentially more
Financial commitmentLowerHigher

My initial recommendation is to Renovate

Here’s why:

  • You are potentially protecting one of your biggest financial advantages.
  • A $100,000 investment is substantially less than purchasing a $600,000 property.
  • You may be able to solve your space problems without taking on a substantially larger mortgage.

However, there is one important exception: If your current home cannot realistically accommodate your long-term needs, moving may be the better investment in your quality of life.